Port Allegany High School recognizes a male and female athlete of the month each month September through May.  In September 2023, Henry Kisler, Class of 2024 and Isla Lehmier, Class of 2026 were selected followed by Aidan Clark (2025) and Kendra Meade (2026) for October; Juuso Young (2026) and Julie Smith (2025) for November and Austin Hamilton (2025) and Savannah Hart (2026) for December  In January 2024, Levi Wilfong (2024) and Brynn Evens (2026) were selected followed by Henry Troupe (2024) and Willow Sauers (2025) for February; Aiden Bliss (2026) and Madison Errick (2026) for March; Kole Kisko (2024) and Lily Lehmeir (2026) for April and Owen Kisler (2026) and Alayna Palmer (2027) for May.  The athletes are pictured (left to right) Isla Lehmier, Henry Kisler, Kendra Meade, Aidan Clark, Julie Smith, Austin Hamilton, Savannah Hart, Levi Wilfong, Brynn Evens, Willow Sauers, Lily Lehmier, Maddie Errick, Alayna Palmer and Owen Kisler.